Traffic on U.S. 1 in Monroe County was bogged down for miles on Tuesday, Nov. 17 due to a crash involving an oil tanker and a later vehicle fire, according to the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office.
MCSO officials said that they did not have an expected time for when the road would be reopened. The incident involved a gas tanker that had rolled over, causing an explosion risk. About a half-hour after the oil tanker incident, a vehicle caught fire at Mile Marker 64.
Drivers are encouraged to avoid U.S. 1 from mile marker 59 to 64.
Videos posted by MCSO deputies on the agency’s official social media account showed the vehicle, a white pickup truck, engulfed in flames. Plumes of black smoke wafted from the area as the lights from the vehicles of emergency responders flashed in the background.
Earlier in the day, Sheriff Rick Ramsey was at the site of the oil tanker crash and told residents in another social media video that the tanker was on the shoulder of the road but was leaking fuel “into the waterway.”
“We’ve got a big hazard,” he said. “This thing could explode, potentially. We’ve got emergency services on scene … We cannot pass traffic for safety reasons. This is probably going to be going most of the day.”
By 8:30 a.m., traffic was already backed up in both directions, he said.
Law enforcement agencies, as well as the Coast Guard and officials from the Department of environmental Protections, were at the site.
Additional information regarding any potential injuries was not immediately available Tuesday morning.
Leesfield Shapiro
Leesfield Shapiro has been representing the victims of Florida crashes for five decades. Our skilled trial attorneys handle every case with the compassion and tenacity necessary to achieve the best possible outcome on behalf of every client. Leesfield Shapiro has obtained record and historic results for crash victims in some of the most heartbreaking and complex motor vehicle accident cases that have occurred in the state. One such result includes a $95 million verdict obtained on behalf of a family who lost their daughter and whose son sustained catastrophic injuries as the result of a wrong way drunk driver on I-95. The drunk driver hit the family head-on as they were driving to the airport so that their daughter could board a flight to attend her medical school’s orientation. Tragically, she died in this horrific crash. She was 23.
Their then-21-year-old son suffered permanent injuries that left him needing round-the-clock care and a wheelchair. He was unable to speak due to his injuries.
A jury awarded $57 million to the son and $38 million to the parents. This is among the largest motor vehicle accident verdicts in Florida.
Ira Leesfield, the firm’s founder and managing partner, obtained a $19.8 million verdict against Honda for a defective motorcycle design involving the vehicle’s kickstand. IN that instance, Mr. Leesfield represented a young man who was riding his motorcycle when the kickstand suddenly and erroneously deployed in the middle of the ride. The result was a terrifying and horrific crash that left him paralyzed.
Partner Justin B. Shapiro previously represented a family in a wrongful death pedestrian case, resulting in a $36,960,000 jury verdict.
Mr. Shapiro and Trial Attorney Eric Shane obtained a $1,320,000 recovery for a Key West motor scooterist. In that case, our client was hit by a driver who failed to stop at a stop sign, sending him airborne before he crashed onto the asphalt. He suffered an ankle fracture that required surgery. With an auto insurance policy of about $10,000, Mr. Shapiro and Mr. Shane began to explore other avenues of liability for their client and discovered that the driver was unable to see oncoming traffic due to overgrown vegetation on the property adjacent to intersection, a violation of Key West’s city ordinances.
While seemingly ordinary, overgrown vegetation and other visibility obstructions can present a danger and leave homeowners vulnerable to liability, as was the case in this instance, Mr. Shane said.
“This case serves as an important reminder that property owners have a responsibility to ensure their landscaping does not create hazards for the public,” he said. “When they do, however, they must be held accountable.”
Leesfield Shapiro: In the Community
The firm has also tried countless motor vehicle accident cases out of Monroe County, where Leesfield Shapiro has had an office since at least the 1980s. The firm’s roots in the area go back to about three years before it was established in 1976. At that time, Mr. Leesfield was beginning his career as a plaintiff’s attorney and was representing a family whose young teen was involved in an accident. The firm has spent decades representing injured Monroe County residents and visitors ever since in cases of negligent security at hotels, boating accidents, motor vehicle accidents and more.
The firm has also been avidly involved in the community and contributes annually to organizations providing essential services to those in need. In 2024, Leesfield Shapiro and The Leesfield Family Foundation started a scholarship named in honor of beloved Key West High School basketball coach and teacher, Dexter Butler. That scholarship will be awarded for its third consecutive year in May at Key West High School’s Class Night. Both male and female students are eligible to apply.
Recently, Mr. Leesfield and Mr. Shapiro attended an event to celebrate the career of Judge Mark H. Jones and his lifetime commitment to the Monroe County judiciary.
Previous Cases
In decades of representing the victims of horrific crashes on Florida roads, our attorneys have seen firsthand the devastating effects of these traumatic incidents on families.
Trial Attorney Carlos Fabano obtained a $5,687,000 motor vehicle accident verdict on behalf of our pedestrian client. In that case, our client was attempting to cross the street in the dim morning hours in Miami when a speeding driver failing to use the vehicle’s headlights ploughed into him. The driver of the vehicle was the employee of a rental car company and was using a company car at the time of the crash. Our client suffered severe and painful injuries and underwent a below-the-knee amputation on his right leg.
A Key West crash involving a prominent local businessman resulted in a record verdict. In that case, our client had the green light at an intersection when an ambulance at a red light unexpectedly plowed through the road and hit him. In the crash, he was thrown into a cement wall, resulting in permanent injuries.
The ambulance driver claimed he was on his way to an emergency and had the right of way, however, this driver failed to deploy the necessary lights and sirens. Without these indicators, our client had no idea that the ambulance would not stop when at the red light and so he proceeded to cross the intersection.
Previously, Leesfield Shapiro obtained an $8.5 million settlement following a $27 million arbitration award for the family of a young woman who was killed by a pickup truck driver while attempting to cross the street. The woman, a wife and mother of two, was visiting Florida from her home in Toronto, Canada, when she was crushed by a pickup truck. The driver in that case claimed to not have seen her.
In a case involving a bicyclist who was hit while stopped on the side of the road on the Overseas Highway in Key West, the firm secured a $5,350,000 settlement. In that case, the bicyclist was hit by a driver who was distracted by their car’s GPS.
The firm previously recovered $3 million for a mother and son injured in a bicycle incident.
In a previous case involving a scooter accident, the firm obtained a $1 million award.
Key West Injury Lawyer Blog


